Why biopic recent history to the point where the character or focal personae are still alive? I recently saw
Frost/ Nixon and, more recently,
Holy Flying Circus. I've also seen the original programmes of Frost interviewing Nixon and pretty much all of Python that's available. It made me start thinking- is either film worth doing? If so, what's the point in them changing things?
I'll say this- like with so many of my posts, this isn't going to have a definitive answer. To the point where I've actually said as much before we go on.
Dramatic licence and creative adaptation are all well and good. But when it comes to Frank Langella
shouting "When the president does it, it's not illegal" while the real Nixon merely stated it as quiet fact in the true interview, all for the purposes of a crescendo, a turning of the tables in the dramatised debate, is it really worth it? If you want that, then have it. But make a political drama, write a new story, in which such an event occurs. Don't change history. More importantly, don't change what was a great, subtle moment in the undoing of Nixon by Frost. It cheapens the very interview it was inspired by.
It was a similar affair, but much more widely and liberally apportioned, with
Holy Flying Circus. This 'dramatic re-telling', as it was marketed, of the furore around
The Life of Brian felt as though it was trying too hard to be Python-esque in the weird and whacky but organic way that they were, in the same way that Eoin Colfer's
And Another Thing tried to hard to capture the absurd humour of Douglas Adams'
Hitchhiker's Trilogy (of Five). The end result was something forced, a bit of a mess.